Grill Marks on the Stovetop: Best Grill Pan Options in Bare Iron, Enamel and Nonstick

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. This doesn’t change our recommendations or the price you pay.

The best grill pan gives you seared stripes on steak, chicken and vegetables when the backyard grill is covered in snow or you simply don’t have one. The ridges lift food above the fat, so you get browned lines instead of a full sear, and the grooves catch the drippings.

Material decides most of the experience. Bare cast iron is cheap and nearly indestructible but heavy and needs seasoning. Enameled iron skips the seasoning at a higher price. Nonstick aluminum is light and wipes clean but has a lower heat ceiling. A two-burner reversible adds a flat griddle side for pancakes.

We compared six stovetop grill pans across all four styles, using their Amazon listings only. We quote oven-safe temperatures and cooktop compatibility exactly as each listing gives them, flag the fields that are empty, and point out the one pick that says outright it won’t work on induction.

Our Top Grill Pan Picks at a Glance

Price key: $ under $50 · $$ $50–$100 · $$$ $100–$175 · $$$$ $175+. Prices change often; check Amazon for today’s price.

1. Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan, 10.5″: Best Overall

Lodge’s Square Cast Iron Grill Pan is the plain, heavy, ridged square most people picture when they hear “grill pan.” The cooking surface is 10.5 inches across, and the listed footprint of 17.25 by 10.5 inches includes the long handle and a helper handle on the far side. It arrives seasoned, so it is ready to cook on.

Lodge pitches it for a “steakhouse sear at home,” with ridges that leave grill marks and channel excess grease away from the food. Day to day, that means preheating it on a burner, laying down steaks, burgers, salmon or thick slices of zucchini, and letting the iron’s stored heat do the marking. Cast iron is slow to heat but holds that heat once it gets there, which is why the listing talks about even heat and fewer hot spots.

The finish is “made with only iron and oil,” and Lodge says the pan is free from PFOA, PTFE and PFAS. The listing names stovetops, ovens, grills and campfires as places to use it, so you can sear on the stove and finish thick chops in the oven, or take it camping. It does not give a maximum oven temperature, and it doesn’t mention induction by name. Care is the usual cast iron routine: wash, dry it fully and wipe on a thin layer of oil.

It suits anyone buying a first grill pan, cooks who already own Lodge skillets and like the routine, and anyone who wants one pan for both the range and the campfire. Plan on two hands when it is hot and full.

Why we like it

• Stove-to-oven-to-campfire versatility
• Lifetime limited warranty field
• Low price tier

Watch out for

The listing gives no oven-safe temperature and doesn’t name induction, and bare iron rusts if it is left wet.

Check Price on Amazon →

2. Lodge 12.5 x 8″ Enameled Cast Iron Grill Pan: Best Rectangular Single-Burner

Lodge’s 12.5 x 8 inch grill pan trades the familiar square for a rectangle. The longer shape gives room for a row of sausages, a bundle of asparagus or kebab skewers laid end to end, while the narrow width keeps it over a single burner. The listing lists the color as red.

There’s one oddity to know before ordering. The title calls it “Enameled Cast Iron,” but the bullets describe Lodge’s standard seasoning: oil baked into the iron, pre-seasoned with “100% natural vegetable oil,” and a note that a rust-looking spot may appear on arrival and can be scoured, dried and oiled. Those are care instructions for seasoned iron, so check the product photos and the box to see which surface you received before you choose a care routine.

In use, it behaves like other Lodge cast iron. The listing says it handles “any kitchen cooktop, oven, grill, and open flame,” and that cast iron is slow to heat but holds heat for edge-to-edge cooking. Lodge says it is made in the USA from material free of PFOA and PTFE, and that the family-owned company was founded in 1896. No oven temperature limit or warranty term is listed.

It suits cooks who grill long, skinny foods more than steaks, and who want a lower-profile pan, listed at 1.75 inches tall, that slides into a cabinet more easily than a deep skillet-style grill.

Why we like it

• Long shape for skewers and sausages
• Made in the USA, per listing
• Fits over one burner

Watch out for

The title and bullets disagree on whether the surface is enameled or seasoned, and no warranty term or oven limit is listed.

Check Price on Amazon →

3. Le Creuset Enameled Cast Iron Square Grill Pan, 10.25″: Best Enameled Cast Iron

Le Creuset’s Enameled Cast Iron Square Grill Pan is a 10.25-inch ridged square in matte black enamel, part of what the listing calls the Alpine Outdoor Collection. It is built to move between the kitchen and the backyard: the listing says it nests with other Alpine Outdoor pieces for storage and has a low profile so grill hoods can close over it.

Because the iron is coated in enamel, Le Creuset says it is ready to use and needs no seasoning. The matte black enamel is described as resisting dulling, staining, chipping, cracking and rusting, and Le Creuset says it develops a patina over time that improves cooking performance. Oversized handles are meant for safe lifting with mitts on.

The heat rating stands out. The listing says it is safe on “regulated and unregulated heat surfaces up to 842°F/450°C,” which covers a hot gas burner, the oven and a grill grate. It is also listed as safe for the dishwasher and for metal utensils. The one hard limit is in plain words: “Not induction compatible.” Sizing is listed at 13.7 by 10.25 by 3.2 inches with handles; no weight is given.

It suits cooks on gas or radiant electric ranges who want enameled iron with no seasoning routine, and grill owners who want a pan they can set on the grates for fish, vegetables or small foods that would fall through.

Why we like it

• 842°F heat limit
• No seasoning routine
• Works on an outdoor grill

Watch out for

Induction households should skip it: the listing says it is not induction compatible.

Check Price on Amazon →

4. Le Creuset Toughened Non-Stick PRO Grill Pan, 11″: Best Premium Nonstick

Le Creuset’s Toughened Non-Stick PRO Grill Pan is an 11-inch nonstick grill pan sold with a matching nylon brush for scrubbing between the ridges. Where the brand’s enameled pans rely on iron and enamel, this one is built around a nonstick surface that Le Creuset describes as triple-reinforced and “now 4x stronger,” without saying what it is compared against.

The interior is textured, which the listing says promotes browning and searing and wipes clean easily. Day to day, that means less oil for lean chicken or fish, and cleanup that is mostly a wipe and a pass with the included brush. Le Creuset says the brush has non-abrasive nylon bristles that are safe for all cookware surfaces, including nonstick.

Compatibility is broad. The listing says it works on all cooktops and is oven safe up to 500°F, with tempered glass lids rated to 425°F. A lid isn’t named in the title, so treat that line as the rating for compatible Le Creuset lids. Stay-cool ergonomic handles are listed for quick, comfortable movement. The listed package size is 19.9 by 11 by 3 inches, and there is no weight or warranty term in the specs.

It suits induction owners who want a premium nonstick grill pan, and anyone who prefers easy release to the seasoning upkeep of bare cast iron.

Why we like it

• Works on all cooktops
• Brush included for the ridges
• 500°F oven rating

Watch out for

It is the least popular pick by sales rank, and the listing gives no warranty term or weight.

Check Price on Amazon →

5. Amazon Basics Cast Iron Reversible Grill/Griddle: Best Two-Burner Reversible

Amazon Basics’ Reversible Rectangular Grill/Griddle is a slab of pre-seasoned cast iron with ridges on one side and a flat griddle on the other. At about 20 by 10.6 inches, it is the kind of long rectangle that cooks usually lay across two burners, though the listing itself doesn’t say so, so measure your burner spacing first.

The appeal is two pans in one. Flip to the ridged side for burgers, chicken thighs, peppers and onions; flip to the flat side for pancakes, eggs, bacon or grilled cheese. Built-in handles at each end are described as user friendly, and the listing says cast iron gives even heat distribution and retention.

The listing is refreshingly direct about care and safety. It says the pan is oven safe to 500 degrees Fahrenheit, that pre-seasoned products “don’t have non-stick function,” and that it is hand wash only. It also tells you to “Always use hot-pads, oven mitts, or potholders” when moving it on or off the stove or oven. The specs list it at 11.02 pounds and under an inch tall, so it stores flat but is a two-handed lift.

It suits households that cook breakfast and dinner for several people, and anyone who wants a griddle surface without buying a separate pan.

Why we like it

• Grill and griddle in one
• Biggest cooking area
• 500°F oven rating

Watch out for

At 11.02 pounds it is heavy to flip and clean, and it must be hand washed.

Check Price on Amazon →

6. SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan with Lid, 9.5″: Best Budget Nonstick for Induction

SENSARTE’s Nonstick Grill Pan with Lid is a 9.5-inch square of die-cast aluminum with a Swiss ILAG nonstick coating, raised ribs for grill marks and a pour spout on each side. It is the lightweight answer to cast iron: no seasoning, quick to heat and easy to lift with one hand.

The listing says the coating keeps food from sticking “even with minimal oil” and cleans with a wipe of a paper towel or a rinse, and that it is free of PFOA and PFOS. A thick stainless steel base lets it work on gas, electric, induction and glass or ceramic cooktops, and SENSARTE says the base spreads heat evenly and quickly. The ribs keep fat down in the grooves, and the spouts make it easy to pour off excess fat and liquid as you go.

A Bakelite handle is described as comfortable and cool to the touch. The title says a lid comes with it, which helps melt cheese on burgers or keep a thick chicken breast cooking through without drying out; the bullets don’t describe the lid’s material. No oven temperature is given, so keep it on the stovetop unless the manual says otherwise. The spec fields for warranty, weight and model are empty.

It suits apartment cooks, induction owners and anyone who wants grill marks on a weeknight without the weight and care of iron.

Why we like it

• Induction-ready base
• Pour spouts for grease
• Comes with a lid

Watch out for

No oven-safe temperature or warranty term is listed, and the listed dimensions don’t match the 9.5-inch square in the title.

Check Price on Amazon →

How We Chose the Best Grill Pans

We limited our picks to pans in stock and sold by Amazon.com or the brand’s own store, skipped every product line already covered in our guide to pans for gas stoves, and compared what each listing actually says:

• Material: bare seasoned cast iron, enameled cast iron or nonstick aluminum, and what each needs for care.
• Cooktop fit: whether the listing names induction, and the one that rules it out.
• Heat limits: the oven-safe or surface temperature, quoted as written, or “not stated.”
• Shape and size: square, rectangular, round or a two-burner reversible.
• Weight, warranty and rank: the listed weight, the warranty field and Amazon sales rank.

Grill Pan Buying Guide

Best Grill Pan for Stovetop Cooking: Cast Iron or Nonstick?

Cast iron, like the Lodge square, the Lodge rectangle and the Amazon Basics reversible, holds a lot of heat, which helps print dark grill marks, but it is heavy and bare iron needs drying and oiling. Nonstick, like the SENSARTE and the Le Creuset Toughened Non-Stick PRO, heats faster, weighs less and wipes clean, though the SENSARTE listing gives no oven limit. Enameled iron, like the Le Creuset square, sits in between: no seasoning, high heat, a premium price.

Best Induction Grill Pan

Induction needs a magnetic base. The SENSARTE names induction outright, and the Le Creuset nonstick says it is compatible with all cooktops. The Le Creuset enameled square is the exception: its listing says “Not induction compatible.” The Lodge listings mention stovetops or “any kitchen cooktop” without naming induction, and the Amazon Basics listing doesn’t address it, so test with a magnet or check the manual before buying for an induction range.

Best Nonstick and Ceramic Grill Pans

None of our six picks is sold as a ceramic-coated grill pan. The two nonstick picks use different approaches: SENSARTE cites a Swiss ILAG coating free of PFOA and PFOS, and Le Creuset describes a triple-reinforced, textured nonstick surface rated to 500°F in the oven. If “ceramic” matters to you, read the coating line on the listing rather than the color in the photos, since enamel and granite-look finishes are different things.

Square, Round or a Reversible Grill/Griddle?

A 10- to 11-inch square, like the Lodge and Le Creuset squares, fits a standard burner and holds two steaks or four burgers. The Lodge 12.5 x 8 rectangle suits long foods. The Le Creuset nonstick is round, which matches a burner’s heat pattern. A reversible slab like the Amazon Basics gives you the most room plus a flat griddle side, but at about 20 inches long it needs two burners and lots of storage space.

Best Grill Pans for an Outdoor Grill

A grill pan on the grates keeps fish, shrimp and chopped vegetables from falling through. Look for a listing that names grills: the Lodge square lists grills and campfires, the Lodge rectangle lists grills and open flame, and the Le Creuset enameled square has a low profile so the grill hood can close and a rating up to 842°F. Skip nonstick with plastic-type handles over open flame unless the maker says it is safe there.

Smoke, Ridges and Indoor Grilling

Ridges lift food above the fat, which is the point, but rendered fat in the grooves smokes at high heat. Pour it off as you cook (the SENSARTE has spouts for this), pat meat dry, and run the vent fan before you start. If your kitchen fills with smoke every time you sear, a stronger hood helps; our range hood guide compares ducted and ductless options.

Hot Handles, Grease Fires and Your Home

A preheated grill pan is one of the hottest things on your stove, and its grooves hold fat. A few habits keep it safe:

• Treat every iron handle as hot. Cast iron handles heat up with the pan. The Amazon Basics listing tells you to “Always use hot-pads, oven mitts, or potholders,” and our oven mitt guide covers mitts rated for high heat.
• Keep a lid nearby. The NFPA’s cooking safety page says unattended cooking is the leading cause of kitchen fires and advises keeping a lid beside the pan: if a small grease fire starts, slide the lid over the pan and turn off the burner.
• Clear the stovetop. NFPA also says to keep oven mitts, wooden utensils, food packaging and towels away from the stovetop.
• Check your coverage. Homeowners and renters policies generally cover fire damage from a covered loss. Our Ohio homeowners insurance guide and renters insurance costs in Ohio explain what to look for.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best grill pan for most kitchens?

The Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan is our top pick. It ranks #3 in Amazon’s Grill Pans category, sits in the lowest price tier, carries a lifetime limited warranty field, and its listing names stovetops, ovens, grills and campfires.

What is the best induction grill pan?

The SENSARTE names induction outright, and the Le Creuset Toughened Non-Stick PRO says it is compatible with all cooktops. Avoid the Le Creuset enameled square for induction: its listing says it is not induction compatible.

Can you use a grill pan on an outdoor grill?

Some are made for it. The Lodge square lists grills and campfires, and the Le Creuset enameled square is rated up to 842°F with a low profile so a grill hood can close. Check the listing before putting a nonstick pan over open flame.

Is there a good microwave grill pan?

None of these picks is a microwave grill pan, and none of their listings mention microwave use. Microwave browning pans are a separate product type, so follow that maker’s instructions rather than putting a stovetop grill pan in the microwave.

How do I stop a grill pan from smoking indoors?

Pour off fat from the grooves as it collects, pat meat dry, use a moderate preheat and run your range hood from the start. Nonstick pans with pour spouts, like the SENSARTE, make draining easier.

The Bottom Line

For most cooks, the Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan is the best grill pan to start with: inexpensive, popular and usable from stovetop to campfire. The Lodge 12.5 x 8 rectangle suits long foods, and the Amazon Basics reversible adds a griddle side for big breakfasts. For no-seasoning iron with the highest heat rating, the Le Creuset enameled square is the pick, as long as you don’t cook on induction. For nonstick, the Le Creuset Toughened Non-Stick PRO works on every cooktop, and the SENSARTE brings induction compatibility, a lid and pour spouts to the budget tier.

Wondering how your policy would handle a stovetop grease fire? Call Jeff Smith’s State Farm office at (740) 354-7747 or request a free coverage review.